Home Entertainment California Can Subsidize Production. It Cannot Rebuild Hollywood by Itself.

California Can Subsidize Production. It Cannot Rebuild Hollywood by Itself.

California is offering Hollywood more money at precisely the moment when Hollywood is less clearly a place.

On November 2, Governor Gavin Newsom proposed raising the state’s annual film and television tax-credit program from $750 million to at least $1 billion, extending it through 2040, expanding eligibility to above-the-line compensation, increasing independent-film funding to $100 million annually and rewarding companies that commit to multiple California productions. The proposal arrives alongside a federal bill that would establish a 20 percent tax credit for qualifying American production labor, with bonuses potentially raising the credit to 30 percent.

The proposals are being presented as an industrial rescue. They are also, whether their authors intend it or not, a form of cultural policy. They ask what California is preserving when it subsidizes production: jobs, studios, tax revenue, independent filmmaking, a famous brand or the idea that Hollywood still represents a particular kind of American imagination.

The numbers are real. They are not the whole story.

California’s existing program has plainly attracted activity. The state says the first year of its expanded credit produced $8.25 billion in direct production spending, more than 43,000 cast and crew jobs and over 8,600 filming days. Those figures matter. A production economy is not imaginary simply because its advocates use enthusiastic arithmetic.

But production spending is not the same thing as cultural recovery. The California Legislative Analyst’s Office, evaluating the earlier proposal to raise the annual credit to $750 million, concluded that the incentive would increase production activity and help California maintain a share of worldwide production. It also found that the broader economic benefits to the state were difficult to establish after accounting for lost revenue and economic activity displaced from other sectors.

This is not a contradiction. A tax credit can attract a television series that might otherwise film elsewhere. It can keep a soundstage occupied, a rental house open and a crew member employed. It does not follow that the credit produces a net economic gain, a stable career system or a more adventurous film culture.

The state’s own language is revealing. The proposal promises “stable, long-term work,” while the program’s mechanics largely measure qualified expenditures, eligible wages, filming days and approved projects. Those are useful administrative categories. They are not yet a labor culture.

A production job is not necessarily a career.

Hollywood has always depended on collaborative labor, though its mythology prefers directors, stars and executives. Editors, sound mixers, visual-effects artists, composers, costume workers, production assistants, location managers and countless other craftspeople make the finished work possible. California’s new standalone post-production incentive is valuable partly because it recognizes that the work does not end when the cameras stop.

It also reveals the instability of the present system. Post-production can travel after a project has already been filmed. The state is therefore attempting to hold on to another segment of an industry whose parts have become geographically mobile.

The question is not whether these workers are creative. They are. The question is whether public support gives them continuity or merely makes California competitive in another round of corporate location-shopping.

A production economy can report tens of thousands of jobs while leaving workers with irregular schedules, uncertain annual income, limited benefits and no durable relationship with the companies that employ them. The state should eventually report not only how many people worked on subsidized productions, but how many returned, how many earned a living wage across the year, how many entered through apprenticeship and how many remained in the industry long enough to build a life.

Otherwise “Hollywood jobs” becomes a category rather like “filming days”: accurate, countable and strangely indifferent to the lives being counted.

California is trying to subsidize continuity.

The proposed five-percent bonus for companies that commit to at least two qualifying California productions is an important change in logic. The state is no longer asking only, “Can we attract this production?” It is asking whether a company will establish a recurring relationship with California.

That is sensible. One-off productions bring temporary spending. Repeated production can sustain vendors, training systems, facilities and skilled workers. It can create the beginnings of an ecosystem rather than a sequence of unrelated visits.

But continuity cannot be purchased by a bonus alone. A studio may return because the economics are favorable without becoming part of a local culture. It may use California stages, crews and post-production houses while keeping financing, ownership, distribution and intellectual property elsewhere. The state can subsidize the presence of an industry without gaining meaningful influence over its decisions.

This is the central difficulty of the current rescue effort. California is trying to preserve the result of an older historical system without necessarily reproducing the conditions that created it.

Hollywood was never only an incentive.

California’s film industry developed through geography, climate, labor, immigration, technical infrastructure, exhibition and the concentration of creative workers. It developed through studio ownership and apprenticeship, but also through small suppliers, independent producers, film schools, theaters and the peculiar social density of a place where people could find one another between projects.

Tax incentives can help maintain some of that physical infrastructure. They cannot, by themselves, recreate long-term studio affiliation, local audience formation or the old relationship between a place and the stories made there.

Nor can they guarantee that the work produced will be ambitious. A tax credit is indifferent to whether a film is formally daring, politically useful, forgettable or simply expensive. That indifference is not necessarily a flaw; governments should be cautious about pretending to know which artworks deserve to exist. But it does mean that a production incentive should not be advertised as though it were an artistic program.

The strongest public case for supporting film is not that film is glamorous, historically important or capable of generating flattering publicity for a governor. It is that culture includes forms of work the market may not reliably sustain. That argument would require attention to first-time filmmakers, small post-production companies, regional stories, repertory cinemas, film archives and projects too modest or unusual to win a bidding contest among states.

“Independent” is not a magic word.

Newsom’s proposal would raise annual funding for independent productions to $100 million. That may broaden the program’s reach. It may also allow the word “independent” to perform considerable political work.

Independence is not determined by budget size alone. A modest film may be artistically cautious, while a large production may give an unusual filmmaker genuine freedom. The more useful questions concern ownership, financing, distribution, labor conditions, artistic control and audience access.

California should therefore publish more than the number of independent projects it supports. It should identify whether those projects come from first-time filmmakers or established companies, whether they reach theaters or durable public platforms, whether artists retain meaningful control and whether the program creates opportunity beyond the familiar network of production entities that already knows how to apply for public money.

A subsidy can reduce financial risk without increasing artistic risk. Those are not the same thing.

The federal credit could nationalize the bidding war.

H.R. 10582, the Motion Picture, Television, and Entertainment Revitalization Act, was introduced on September 24 and referred to the House Ways and Means Committee. It has not been enacted. The bill would create a federal credit based on qualified compensation for feature films, television pilots and television seasons produced primarily in the United States, with additional bonuses for certain productions.

A federal incentive could bring some work back from overseas. It could also make the competition among American states more expensive. California, Georgia, New York, New Mexico and other jurisdictions would still negotiate over location, labor, facilities and public subsidy. The country might regain production without regaining a concentrated Hollywood.

Georgia offers a useful warning. According to reporting by The Associated Press, production spending there fell from $4.4 billion in 2022 to $2.3 billion in the most recent fiscal year, while the number of productions declined from 412 to 245. A generous incentive did not make the state immune to strikes, changing corporate strategies, overseas competition or a contraction in the number of shows being made.

That is the uncomfortable fact beneath the rhetoric of revival: governments can compete for production, but they cannot compel companies to make more films, maintain old employment patterns or preserve the cultural ambitions associated with a previous era.

What should California actually preserve?

The answer cannot simply be “Hollywood.” The word now describes several different things at once: a place, a workforce, a collection of studios, a set of intellectual properties, a tax base, a political symbol and a global brand.

Those meanings do not always point in the same direction.

A policy that keeps expensive productions in California may strengthen facilities while doing little for small theaters. A policy that attracts recurring series may create employment while narrowing the range of projects that receive financing. A policy that expands independent-film funding may produce cultural breadth, or it may reward companies that have learned to wear independence as an administrative costume.

The public should be told which result is being purchased. If the goal is employment, the state should measure worker income, repeat employment, benefits and training. If the goal is economic development, it should disclose the value of credits, administrative costs and net fiscal effects. If the goal is cultural preservation, it should examine first-time artists, regional storytelling, distribution, exhibition and archival access.

At present, the rhetoric moves easily among all three goals. That is politically convenient and intellectually imprecise.

California may succeed in attracting more productions. That would be a legitimate achievement. It would not, by itself, mean that Hollywood has returned.

Hollywood was never merely the place where cameras operated. It was a system of labor, fantasy, memory, exploitation, apprenticeship and public attention. A tax credit can pay for production. It can keep a stage lit and a crew working. It cannot decide whether the culture being produced is durable, adventurous or worth preserving.

That decision belongs to the public, the artists and the institutions that choose what to finance, show, remember and pass forward. The state can help create the conditions. It cannot purchase the result.